Todd Landon Barnes
  • Home
  • Curriculum Vitae
  • Publications
  • Reviews

Effing the Ineffable: Exploring the Limits of Reading and Writing

Rhetoric 1A; Section 5
Class Hours: TTh 2-3:30
Instructor: Todd Barnes
Office hours:        TTh 4-5 and by appointment
toddbarnes@berkeley.edu

This course aims to prepare students for the critical reading, thinking and writing challenges they will face at Berkeley and beyond.  In this course, we will explore the idea of the “ineffable” as we read challenging texts by authors who, through various rhetorical strategies, attempt to articulate the inarticulable.  By exploring a range of philosophic, literary, scientific and sociological texts, will survey how various thinkers (and their respective disciplines) have grappled with and often tried to expand the limits of representation.  While considering the ineffable as something both semantically unintelligible and morally unspeakable, we will be investigating the elusive boundary between different forms of representation and contents that always seem to exceed or escape such formal bounds.     

We will examine and discuss a host of attempts to “eff the ineffable” within a variety of representational contexts.  Throughout the semester, we will interrogate language’s attempts to represent experience, film’s attempts to represent dramatic texts, images’ attempts to represent affect, sociology’s and biology’s attempts to represent race and gender, cartography’s attempts to represent space, and history’s attempts to represent the past.  All these discussions will ultimately return us to the ineffable’s relation to the problem of “writer’s block” as students attempt to eff the ineffable in a series of compositions.

Our readings, writings, and discussions will be guided by the following questions: What is the ineffable? Is it an epistemological category, or are its contours shaped morally? Where does interpretive reading end and argumentative writing begin?  What activities exceed the limits of reading and writing?  Where might we locate seeing, loving, feeling, remembering, performing or experiencing?  Do these activities exist inside or outside the purview of reading and writing?  Do these experiences serve as metaphors for reading and writing, or are reading and writing metaphors serving the activity and receptivity of such experiences? 

Required Texts:

• Writing Analytically. ed. Rosenwasser and Stephen. Heinle: 4th edition, 2005.
• Style: Ten Lessons on Clarity and Grace. Joseph Williams. Ninth Edition.
• A course reader which will include work by the following writers: F. Nietzsche, R. Barthes, M. Omi, J. Berger, G. Lakoff and M. Johnson, J.L. Austin, M. Foucault, M. de Certeau, R. Burt, C. West, W. Shakespeare, W. Benjamin, L. Althusser, T. Eagleton, Artaud, A. and J. McGann. The course reader will be available at Replica Copy on Oxford by 9/2.

Participation/Attendance

This class will not be possible without your participation.  Unlike some courses, the success of this course depends on your contributions, your labor, and your perspective. In addition to the authors we read together, your work will form a central focus of our attempts to understand what it means to articulate the ineffable.
 
Papers (late/format)

No late papers will be accepted.  Your essays need not be perfect, but I do expect them to be on time.  Papers will be written, reviewed and returned in accordance with a shared schedule.  Late papers threaten to jam what I hope will be the smooth machinery of the review process.

All papers are to be typed and formatted according to the most recent MLA guidelines.

Plagiarism

Plagiarism, etymologically, means kidnapping.  Do not steal the brainchildren of others.  We do not want to encourage the fear of conception or downplay the connection between discourse and intercourse; however, those who engage in plagiarism will suffer the consequences set forth by the university.  If you have any questions about what constitutes plagiarism, see one of the instructors or the university’s guidelines at:

http://www.lib.berkeley.edu/instruct/guides/citations.html#Plagiarism

Disabilities/Accommodations

If you feel you might need any accommodations in order to succeed in this course, please let me know privately as soon as possible.  Also, you might contact the Disabled Students' Program, 260 César Chávez Center #4250, 510.642.0518 (voice) or 510.642.6376 (TTY).

Requirements/Grades

Your weighted grade in the course will be determined according to the following schema:

60% compositions
05% Style exercises
10% WA presentations
15% discussion/blog
10% peer review exercises


Course Blog

The virtual component of this course is substantial.  This semester, we will be utilizing bspace found at http://bspace.berkeley.edu.  Students are required to regularly post comments and feedback through this site. 


Prospective Schedule (subject to minor change):

Week One: Introduction: Reality and Truth

Lakoff, G./Johnson, H.    Excerpt from Metaphors We Live By
Nietzsche, F.             “On Truth and Lies in an Extra-Moral Sense”

8/24     Th:     Introductions/Metaphoricity/Paper One Assigned

Week Two: Metaphors

Rosenwasser, D./Stephen J.    Chapters 1 & 2

9/2      T:    Discuss Lakoff/Johnson/Nietzsche
9/4    Th:    Discuss Nietzsche/Rosenwasser & Stephen/ Paper 1 Due

Week Three: Textuality and the Textual Condition

Eagleton, T.             “What is Literature?”
McGann, J.            “Textual Condition”
Barthes, R.            “Death of the Author”
Rosenwasser/Stephen       Chapter 3

9/9    T:    Discuss Eagleton/McGann/Barthes/Blog 1 Due   
9/11    Th:    Discuss Eagleton/McGann/Barthes/Blog 1.2 Due

Blog: Discuss one idea from these three articles in relation to a textual object.

Week Four: Social Spaces and Spatial Publics

de Certeau, M.            “Walking in the City,” “Spatial Stories” &
                                   “Reading as Poaching”
Rosenwasser/Stephen        Chapter 4

9/16    T:    Discuss de Certeau/Rosenwasser & Stephen
9/18    Th:    Discuss de Certeau/Paper 1.2 Due

Week Five: Social Spaces and Spatial Publics (Cont.)

Althusser, L.            “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses”
Foucault, M.            “Panopticism” (excerpt)

9/23    T:      Discuss Althusser/Foucault/Blog 2 Due/Peer Review 1 Due
9/25    Th:    Discuss Althusser/Foucault/Blog 2.2 Due

Blog: Discuss two of these five articles in relation to a spatial object.
Week Six: Racialized Bodies in Cultural Media

Omi, M./Winant, H.         “Racial Formation in the United States”
Omi, M.                          “In Living Color: Race in American Culture”
West, C.                         “Race and Modernity”

9/30    T:    Discuss Omi/Winant/West/Paper 1.3 Due
10/2    Th:    Discuss Omi/Winant/West/Style Exercises 1 Due

Week Seven: Gendered Bodies in Science

Martin, E.            “The Egg and the Sperm: How Science Has Constructed a
                            Romance Based on Stereotypical Male-Female Roles”
Laqueur, T.          “Orgasm, Generation, and the Politics of Reproductive
                            Biology”

10/7    T:    Discuss Martin/Laqueur/Blog 2 Due
10/9    Th:    Discuss Martin/Laqueur/Blog 2.2 Due

 Blog: Discuss two of these texts in relation to a scientific or filmic object.

Week Eight: Performance and Performativity

Austin, J.L.            Excerpt from How to Do Things With Words (Lectures
                              I/II/III)
Shakespeare, W.   Othello

10/14    T:    Discuss Austin and Othello (Act I)
10/16    Th:    Discuss Othello (Act II)

Week Nine: Performance and Performativity (Cont.)

Artaud, A.                             “Preface,” “On the Balinese Theatre,” “The Theatre and
                                             Cruelty,” & “Theatre of Cruelty (First Manifesto)”
Rosenwasser & Stephen      Chapter 5

10/21    T:    Discuss Othello (Act III) & Artaud   
10/23    Th:    Discuss Othello (Act IV) & Artaud

Week Ten: Writing Workshop

Rosenwasser & Stephen      Chapters 7-9, 11-12

10/28    T:    Writing Workshop/Paper 2.0 Draft Due
10/30    Th:    Writing Workshop/Style Exercises 2 Due



Week Eleven: Images and Re-Imagining

Barthes, R.            Excerpt from Camera Lucida (Part One)
Balázs, B.            Excerpt from Theory of the Film

11/4    T:    Discuss Barthes/Paper 2.2 Due
11/6    Th:    Discuss Barthes

Week Twelve: Images and Re-Imagining (Cont.)

Benjamin, W.            “The Work of Art in the Age of Its Technological Reproducibility”

11/11    T:    Holiday/Blog 3 Due
11/13    Th:    Discuss Benjamin/Blog 3.2 Due

Blog: Discuss two of the three articles in relation to contemporary imaging technologies.

Week Thirteen: History and Experience

Benjamin, W.            “The Storyteller”
Barthes, R.               “Toys”
Barthes, R.               “Plastic”
Woodcock, G.           “The Tyranny of the Clock”

11/18    T:    Discuss Benjamin/Barthes/Woodcock/Blog 4 Due
11/20    Th:    Discuss Benjamin/Barthes/Woodcock/Blog 4.2 Due

Week Fourteen: History and Experience (Cont.)

Foucault, M.            “Introduction” to The Archeology of Knowledge

11/25    T:    Discuss Foucault; Paper 2.3 Due
11/27    Th:    Holiday

Week Fifteen: Final Project Workshop

12/2- 12/4    Effing the Ineffable

Week Sixteen: Final Project Workshop

12/9        Effing the Ineffable
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Curriculum Vitae
  • Publications
  • Reviews